Overview
Challenge Apparel Limited, an export-oriented manufacturer of garments operating at
Multan Road industrial area, Lahore, is famous for employing experienced and skilled
workers. Although the company operated consistently and generated significant export
revenue, it continuously experienced a yearly staff turnover rate of 25-35%, losing 80-100
people out of 400-420 total employees. The present case study attempts to trace how the
problem of turnover, which cost the company approximately Rs. 44.1 lac per annum, turned
from an ordinary HR problem to a business one. Using data collected through the interviews
with production supervisor, a line worker, and the HR manager and supplemented with
industry data, the case reveals five interrelated reasons for attrition in the company: salary,
working conditions, career development, communication, and the impact of the labor
market. The case provides information about WRAP (Workforce Retention Action Plan), a
low-budget four-pillar plan for retention, based on the company’s resources.
Learning Objectives
The current case develops the solution to the retention problem by following the actual
process of dealing with the issue from the very beginning. This includes identifying the root
causes of the turnover problem, which should not be seen as something that happens
inevitably but is caused by certain factors, through SWOT and Fishbone analysis tools. It
also implies quantifying the fuzzy HR problem by making the calculations of the costs of
attrition and using the figures in order to justify the need for change and corresponding
investments. This case encourages working out retention solutions taking into account such
realities of the situation as financial constraints, informal organizational culture, and
capabilities of existing personnel. It allows developing the ability to structure multi
component intervention strategy (compensation, career development, training,
communications) and implement it in reality, assigning responsibility for different steps.
Finally, stress-testing of recommendations is required using the methods of break-even and
sensitivity analysis.